Minthe vs mySymptoms
Choose mySymptoms if
- You use Android. Minthe is iPhone only.
- You want a mature, long-established app rather than a new one.
- You want deep customization: your own foods, symptoms, medications, exercises.
- You want a clinician to review your diary through its web Clinic app.
- You want to see the correlation histograms yourself rather than be handed a verdict.
Choose Minthe if
- You want to know how a finding was reached before you act on it.
- You want false positives explicitly corrected for, not left to your judgment.
- You want each suspect confirmed by a scheduled test, not just listed.
- You want logging to stay free, with photo, barcode and label scanning as well as typing.
- You want lab results, menstrual cycle and alcohol folded into the same analysis.
Where mySymptoms is genuinely better
This is the competitor we take most seriously, and pretending otherwise would be transparent.
- Android, and more than fifteen years of refinement. mySymptoms has been on the App Store since 2010, across both platforms, with 4,045 US ratings averaging 4.6. Minthe launched in 2026 on one. Maturity is a real feature and new apps do not have it.
- Customization depth. Custom foods, meals, medications, exercises and symptoms. If you are tracking something unusual, mySymptoms will probably accommodate it. Minthe lets you add your own foods, homemade mixes and tags, but its symptom set is fixed.
- A route to your clinician. Clinicians get a separate web Clinic app to review a patient’s diary. Minthe gives you a PDF to take to the appointment, which is not the same thing.
- Multiple accounts. Useful for parents tracking a child, and Minthe has no equivalent.
- It shows you the correlation histograms. You can look at the working, which some people much prefer to a verdict.
The two things Minthe does structurally differently
1. It explains how it decides
Minthe learns your usual first, allows for reactions that arrive hours or a day later, filters out results that could be coincidence and treats unlogged days as unknown rather than symptom-free. The timing is not something you can keep adjusting, because a setting you can tweak invites you to tweak it until something looks significant. How it works, in plain English, including what it cannot do.
We could not find a similar description for mySymptoms. That is not an accusation that its analysis is poor, and it may well be good. If mySymptoms publishes one, we will link to it from this page.
2. Confirmation is the product, not a footnote
Both apps will tell you that a food looks suspicious. Only one then asks you to prove it.
When Minthe flags a suspect, it offers a guided trial: spaced challenge days with washout in between, or for a suspected helper food, a week-on week-off block design because carryover is real. At the end it gives a verdict, including "this did not hold up", which is frequently the more useful answer because most people arrive having cut out more than they needed.
This matters more than it sounds. A correlation from a food diary is a hypothesis. Acting on hypotheses is how people end up on diets of eleven foods.
Side by side
| mySymptoms | Minthe | |
|---|---|---|
| Platform | iOS and Android | iPhone only, iOS 18 or later. No Android, no web. The app is in English. |
| Maturity | On the App Store since 2010 | Launched August 2026. No long track record yet. |
| Free tier | None. 7-day free trial, then new entries need a subscription | Unlimited manual logging, free forever. Barcode lookup free, 7 AI scans at install then 3 a week. CSV and PDF export included. |
| Paid price | $9.99/month, $39.99/6 months or $59.99/year | $6.99/month or $39.99/year. Elite $59.99/year for more scans. |
| Logging method | Search or barcode scan into its food database, plus extensive custom items | Photo, barcode, label scan or typed |
| Analysis window | not verified | Yes, from within the hour to the next day. |
| Explains how findings are made | not verified | Yes, in plain English at /method. |
| Guards against chance findings | not verified | Yes. Every result is checked against the chance of a false alarm. |
| Personal base rate contrast | not verified | Yes. Every result is contrasted against your own base rate. |
| Confirmation testing | not verified | Yes. Guided with-and-without tests, days picked at random in advance, with washout. |
| Handling of unlogged days | not verified | Unlogged days treated as unknown. A quiet day you confirm in the end-of-day review counts as a real zero. |
| Stool logging | Yes, Bristol scale | Bristol 1–7, urgency, incomplete evacuation, color flags. |
| Custom foods and symptoms | Extensive: foods, meals, medications, exercises, symptoms | Your own foods, homemade mixes and tags; fixed symptom set |
| More than one person | Yes, as separate accounts | No |
| Clinician access | Web Clinic app for clinicians | Clinician PDF you take with you |
| Lab test import | not verified | Typed in free. Report import $1.99 each on any plan, readable without a plan. Results feed the analysis on Premium, with evidence tiering. |
| Export | PDF and CSV | PDF and CSV, both free |
Checked September 2026. "Not verified" means we could not confirm it from public sources, not that the feature is missing.
How to choose
If you are on Android, use mySymptoms. That is the whole decision.
On iPhone, the useful question is what you want to do with a suspect food once you have one. If you are comfortable reading correlations and running your own reintroductions, mySymptoms gives you more control and more flexibility, and it has years of polish behind it. If you would rather the app corrected for the fact that it just tested two hundred foods at once and then walked you through proving the survivor, that is the gap Minthe was built to fill.
Price now splits them too. mySymptoms charges from the end of a 7-day trial, logging included. Minthe’s logging stays free and only the analysis is paid, so you can find out whether you will keep a diary at all before you spend anything.
Either way, the thing that determines whether you get an answer is logging consistently. Both apps are useless without that, and no amount of statistics fixes a fortnight of gaps.
Not comparing against Minthe? Bearable vs mySymptoms, with Minthe left out of the table.
Minthe is a wellness and self-tracking tool, not a medical device. It does not diagnose or treat any condition and isn't a substitute for professional medical advice. If you have red-flag symptoms such as blood in your stool, unintentional weight loss, difficulty swallowing, persistent vomiting or a fever alongside gut symptoms, see a clinician rather than tracking them.
Frequently asked
What does mySymptoms do better?
Several things. It runs on Android as well as iOS, which Minthe does not. It has been on the App Store since 2010, so it is mature and stable in a way a 2026 app cannot claim. Its customization is deeper, letting you add your own foods, meals, medications, exercises and symptoms, where Minthe keeps a fixed symptom set. It has a food database you can search or scan barcodes into, a web Clinic app for clinicians to review a diary, and multiple accounts if more than one person in a household tracks. And it shows you its correlation reports as histograms and trend charts, so you can look at the working.
What does Minthe do differently?
Two structural things. It checks every result against the chance of a false alarm before showing it. It also does not stop at flagging a suspect. A flagged food gets a scheduled with-and-without test with washout periods, and a verdict at the end. mySymptoms identifies suspect foods; Minthe is built around confirming them.
Is mySymptoms free?
Not any more. mySymptoms is now subscription-only after a 7-day free trial: $9.99 a month, $39.99 for six months or $59.99 a year in the US. Its own FAQ says that after the trial you can no longer add new entries until you upgrade. Minthe’s logging, barcode lookup and export are free with no time limit, and its pattern engine is $39.99 a year. Earlier versions of this page said mySymptoms logging was free, which is no longer true.
Why does checking for chance findings matter?
Because a food diary compares hundreds of foods with your symptoms at once. With that many comparisons some will look guilty purely by coincidence, so a long enough food list will always produce convincing-looking culprits. Minthe checks every result against that risk before it shows you anything, allowing for the fact that foods are often eaten together. We could not find a description of how mySymptoms handles this.
Can I move my data from mySymptoms to Minthe?
Not directly. mySymptoms exports to CSV and PDF, and Minthe also exports CSV, but there is no import path between them. In practice you would start fresh. There is no fixed timeline for Minthe’s first pattern, because it needs a condition rather than a date: a food has to turn up in enough separate meals and you need enough logged days without it for Minthe to know your usual rate. A food you eat most days gets there much sooner than one you have once a month.